Leicester District
National Education Union

8th September 2008

Collaboration, Not Privatisation

Best ever results at KS2 and GCSE show collaborative working can get results.

Schools in the city came up trumps this summer, hitting the ‘very challenging targets’ set by DCSF for school performance. In KS2 and in GCSE results Leicester schools improved by 5% on last year, a magnificent achievement. It was also a measure of what can be achieved in the future if collaborative approaches are properly embedded.

New College, which 3 years ago barely reached 10% on 5 A-Cs at GCSE, this year hit 40%, with 20% if the new measure of 5 grades A-C including English and Maths is used. Hamilton CC reached 53% 5 A-Cs, with 32% including English and Maths.

Much the same was the case in primary, with schools like Eyres Monsell primary, long under the cosh for being below floor targets, reaching the 65% benchmark and also the new target of 55% including English and Maths. All of which demonstrates the level of commitment of headteachers, teaching and non-teaching staff in the city to securing the best for their pupils.

So, you might expect the City Council to be delighted. Dream on.

Last November, facing threats that Education in the city could be outsourced, the council was more than happy to join with the schools and unions in developing a collaborative model for school improvement. The original Transforming Leicester’s Learning (TLL) Action Plan consisted of short-term, urgent intervention to achieve immediate DCSF targets by the summer. This was to be underpinned and succeeded by a larger term, sustainable collaborative strategy. For the last eight months they have talked glowingly about the key to success lying in drawing on the expertise in city schools. But the threat of part of the LA being outsourced has now been withdrawn. Officers jobs are safe; time for Plan B.

Now the council is intent on privatising a whole swathe of city schools as Academies. To prove the need for this cynical abandonment of the collaborative approach they claimed to support, the council has started talking down this year’s results. What a fine way to encourage staff and schools.

In the interest of what they call ‘hard realism,’ officers and politicians claim that this year’s results are:
a) not as good as they look;
b) not sustainable.
With sadness, they note that Leicester has moved up before only to drop back. In other words, this year’s excellent results are just a ‘blip’. Suddenly, the much vaunted TLL Action Plan is not going to produce the results required. Thus, the reversion to the ready made solution provided by the unelected Lord Adonis: make the National Challenge schools - those with under 30% 5 A-Cs including English and Maths - into private Academies.

This disgraceful, casually delivered insult to the dedication and hard work of countless teachers, headteachers and support staff throughout the city over the last year, is a measure of the contempt our so-called leaders have for schools in the city.

In their Secondary Strategy for Change, the council states that it is actively discussing with Leicester University, DMU and Leicester College “proposals for further Academies, based on the need to address the urgent challenges of our ‘National Challenge’ schools and quickly demonstrate positive impact and sustainable improvement.”

Neither of the Universities or the FE College has ever run a secondary school, so it is fascinating to ponder why the LA believes they might have some secret, as yet untapped, formula for sustainable secondary school success. More particularly, if FE and HE have something to contribute, why not take it on for the whole city, so all our schools benefit? Why can they only contribute in the form of Academies? Just as importantly, what does this mean for feeder primary schools? Will some or all of these new Academies be 3-16, leading to the closure of other schools?

Equally, one might ask what happens to parental choice? Under council plans, parents living in the outer ring on the west of the city from Eyres Monsell right round to Beaumont Leys will have no neighbourhood secondary schools other than Academies to choose from. Academy education will be compulsory for these communities. But then we are only talking about working class communities. Why would the council want to offer the less privileged citizens of Leicester the choice of a neighbourhood community comprehensive?

City of Leicester NUT is affiliated to the Anti-Academies alliance, as is Leicester Education Forum. We will be working with colleagues from other unions like NASUWT, UCU, ATL and Unison, and with community organisations and parents to defend comprehensive state education and oppose privatisation of any city schools.

 

Related articles

There Won't Be Any Changes When We Become an Academy. Don't Believe a Word of It! (23rd January 2019)
Still No Need to Rush to Academisation (27th January 2018)
Academies Are Bad For Your Health (8th November 2016)
Two petitions (7th July 2016)
The Government White Paper (30th March 2016)
New academies laws (30th March 2016)
How the government forces schools to become academies (15th January 2016)
Academisation at Uplands JS and Rushey Mead (24th June 2015)
Academies increase divisions between the rich and poor (4th September 2013)
Rushey Mead Secondary School - the fight continues (4th September 2013)
The Fight is on to Save Rushey Mead Secondary School (30th June 2013)
Gove writes to city MPs (12th November 2012)
Academies - not in Leicester! (3rd September 2012)
Academies: the one-way journey (25th May 2012)
Report From the 2012 NUT National Conference (18th April 2012)
Catholic Schools Consultation on Academies (14th November 2011)
Academies in Leicestershire (4th April 2011)
You're Having A Laugh! (4th April 2011)
Say No! to Academies (2nd February 2011)
Academies - get your school on the roll of honour (4th December 2010)
A message from NUT General Secretary, Christine Blower (18th September 2010)
We don't need more academies (14th June 2010)
Don't Trust the Co-op (2nd March 2010)
Sponsor is banned from new academies (18th November 2009)
Academy Up-Front Payment Dropped (9th September 2009)
Support our Schools: Say NO to Leicester Academies (20th June 2009)
Now Riverside May Close (25th March 2009)
Please Support our Schools Say NO to Leicester Academies Campaign (13th February 2009)
Should this man be running an Academy? (22nd January 2009)
Please Support our Schools - Say NO to Leicester Academies (22nd January 2009)
Academies Opposition Goes Across All Unions (3rd December 2008)
5th Annual Report On Academies (3rd December 2008)
Edison Profiting From Education (3rd December 2008)
Snatch! (3rd December 2008)
100 Protest Against Academies (3rd December 2008)
More on Academies: Jeremy Paxman Moment of the Month (10th November 2008)
Please Support our Schools - Say NO to Leicester Academies (10th November 2008)
Primary Academies on the Timetable? (8th September 2008)
Proposals for Academies in Leicester (7th July 2008)
Sellafield to Sponsor An Academy in Cumbria (7th July 2008)
At least three more city academies proposed for Leicester (2nd June 2008)
You Get Academies Whether You Want Them Or Not (7th May 2007)
Academies (3rd April 2006)
A Fresh Fresh Start at New College! (9th January 2006)
Revolt Against Academy in Blair's Backyard (7th November 2005)
Second Division (7th March 2005)
National Adjudicator Questions Value of City Academy (10th January 2005)
City Academy Consultation (6th December 2004)
City Academy gets provisional approval (2nd February 2004)
City Academy Faces Setback (5th May 2003)
The Book of Job's Comforter (6th March 2000)